My Library currently lists 2 recorded programs that do not , Hi, I have not seen the option to record only 1 show. I have moved on from a DVR (machine) to recording into the cloud. Its similar to Philos $20 per month live TV service, but without DVR included. In this video I demonstrate how to record on Spectrum TV App On your Samsung Smart TV with Cloud DVR. Unable to watch channels via a web browser or on Apple TV. LR Score. Not bad. Spectrum TV App Supported Devices. Stream On Demand or live TV anywhere on your favorite devices. Can you record the show after it starts, rewind, pause etc. How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? I just set up my new Spectrum TV service and am shocked that I cannot pause and rewind live TV. Watch live and On Demand shows, and manage your DVR, whether you're home or on the go. Cast from your phone or tablet to a compatible TV with Chromecast. I agree! Currently, you can add it to Spectrum TV Choice, which offers local channels plus your pick of 10 cable channels, or Spectrum TV Stream, which includes locals and a couple dozen pre-selected channels. Is there a way to delete them all at once o, Looking for information on Spectrums cloud dvr service. Spectrum has finally extended their service to our rural area and we're loving the high speed , With one of the more recent updates, my cloud DVR recordings all stop playing and revert back to th, I moved to using the Cloud DVR instead of using the standard DVR from Spectrum. I was considering dropping my Spectrum DVR receivers to save money and try out the cloud DVR service via the Spectrum App on Roku. Looking for information on Spectrums cloud dvr service. 10. Yes. How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? Unfortunately we don't have any information on if or when this feature will be available. 20 Spectrum TV for Roku Devices; 20 Cloud DVR; 15 Spectrum TV - Other Devices; Spectrum TV App 2023 Archive; 20 Spectrum Mobile; 20 Spectrum Mobile; 36 Voice; 27 Digital Phone; Feb 22, 2022 Answer When you pause or rewind live streaming content, a recording is started at the point that the programming is paused or recorded. As they should be. I'm using the Spectrum app on Apple TV. That's right, unlimited streaming cloud DVR recording on Philo. Records both over-the-air and live streaming channels Slick software with lots of DVR creature comforts Excellent audio and video quality for broadcast channels Cons Complicated setup No Roku. It will take you to the 'My DVR' screen on your TV. We were told by a rep that if we get rid of our DVR box and get the Spectrum DVR cloud, we will be able to pause live TV. Before posting a new question, please check out our. For the past week or so, my recordin, Hello my recordings from the cloud all suffer from intermittent stops while watching. You can post for technical support, advice, or just to vent. Fast Forward/Rewind (Press touchpad on remote control, then swipe left/right. It has access to cDVR from what I can tell. On top of that, there is no storage cap. In order to pause live TV, there needs to be a recording function in place like the one you find in a DVR or traditional set top box. Hulu's basic on-demand streaming plan currently costs $6.99 per month, while the ad-free version is $12. You can record up to either 50 or 100 shows to watch whenever you want. What I haven't been able to figure out is how to pause or rewind live tv. You will see how record an episode or a series as well as how to find the recorded content. How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Getting Rid of a Recording Locate the page with program details. This plan you a whopping 10 channels, from almost any channel package (Turner, Viacom, Scripps, whatever), plus you get your local channels and things like PBS and MeTV as a bonus. with cloud dvr and cloud dvr plus you can hit record on a show you are watching and then you are able to pause it. Currently, this feature is not supported on the Spectrum TV App, however you can add CloudDVR, record programming and watch it at a later time. Once you set that up and go to the DVR portion of the site you should see three dots. How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? When you pause or rewind live streaming content, a recording is started at the point that the programming is paused or recorded. How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? In order to pause live TV, you can only currently do that using a traditional DVR. Additionally, they enable you to view them later from your devices remotely. Spectrum TV App Shop Now Watch Online Right Now To view the program information page, select the program from the Scheduled list. I start by accessing the Spectrum guide. Pause, Rewind, & Fast-Forward Control the pace of your programs within live TV and DVR recordings. A straight answer would be great, since every time I call in and ask I am told something different. What is App Cloud Used for and How Can It Help Your Business, How to Remove Apps from iCloud and Save Space. (Probably $15.00 a month) but need confirmation. steveymacjr Posts: 35 Contributor This will help you fix if there was a recording conflict with the higher-ranked series that was recorded previously. That sounds great! If youre only recording half-hour episodes, youd end up with just 25 hours on the DVR, and youd still have a time limit for recordings on top of that. I do not see anything on the app in the menu's, settings, etc, that point me to the cloud dvr. Your feedback is very important for use in determining future upgrades and service changes and we do appreciate you expressing your interest in this service. Sign in or register to get started. Before posting a new question, please check out our, You are currently viewing the Spectrum Community Archives. (Both reps initially said you can record 50 shows, but later clarified that each episode occupies one recording slot.). Or download the Roku mobile app, connect your headphones to. Then attentively read this article if the answer is yes. The only way to add it is to contact customer service and inquire about it on your own. Printable instructions for using CloudDVR, Moving from TiVo to Spectum Cloud DVR questions. So far, though, the company hasnt published any information about this service on its website. Live TV Pause: When using an antenna or connecting cable TV without a set-top box, add a 16GB USB flash drive to your Roku TV and pause live digital broadcast television for up to 90 minutes using Live TV Pause. And just to clarify, I'm not using the app (I don't think). Its interesting to note that the Spectrum TV app is available on Roku, Apple, Android, Apple TV, and Xbox. TechHive helps you find your tech sweet spot. With cDVR, you may plan and record up to 50 live events simultaneously, or up to 100 live shows simultaneously with cDVR Plus. My discovered "f, The Cloud DVR appears to me to have a significant limitation where I cannot find a way to schedule , Recently changed to the cloud dvr so to use it on my Apple TV. You can use the whole home recording on other TVs with the STVA and Cloud DVR if you have Cloud DVR today. Ive had PlayStation Vue, YouTube TV on my Apple TV it was possible to pause live TV then catch back up or go back to watch a scene again Streaming is NOT the same as cable TV. 400 MB internet, Spectrum Select with the sport pack, Cloud DVR and HBO for $152 a month and they could do a 3 year price guarantee. But one question comes up . You are entitled to just three (3) concurrent streams for an account on the Spectrum TV app. Update your Apple TV - Apple Support. Im using a ROKU 4k streaming stick to access the Spectrum app. Just got an AppleTV to ensure a cloud DVR for my Spectrum App. How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? So rewinding live tv is not possible? Ain't gonna happen until everyone pays for theiir own cloud-based DVR ! Anyone seeking streaming convenience without abandoning traditional, live TV. 2 Reply uerik 2 yr. ago That sounds great! This new DVR will cost $4.99 a month and will let you record 50 shows. I'm looking to add silver and use my apple tv's as boxes. TV Select/Silver/Gold and Mi Plan Latino require a Spectrum-purchased Apple TV device. Mar 22, 2021. The other major caveat with Spectrums cloud DVR is that its not available with all of the companys TV packages. Currently, there are no TV's that support Cloud DVR, Cloud DVR is only available on the supported devices listed above. When doing the same on the wireless receiver downstairs, every 10 or 15 seconds, the playback will act like it pauses then skips forward about a second, then resumes playing, only . They support series recordings, meaning the DVR will record all new episodes of a series automatically. Permanent Playback Pause: My connection or your servers? Sounds to me like Spectrum got nervous losing cable customers and just threw together a streaming service to try and keep customers. This worked out great for me because there's always one channel from group A that we couldn't get in . Spectrum Cloud DVR (cDVR) allows you to record TV programs and view them remotely from your devices. $9.99/mo gets you 250 hours of cloud storage, or you can boost that to a whopping 1000 hours for $16.99/mo. We created a new category called Cloud DVR and moved recent related questions to this new location. Can you pause live TV on spectrum? This new DVR option will be available to all Spectrum Stream, Choice, and Essentials customers. JVJ, thanks for that information concerning the different platforms. And I'm not talking about just the streaming cloud DVR either. The downside is after 90 days it will auto delete the recordings from your DVR. Those on their legacy fuboTV Standard Plan have 30 Hours of DVR storage included, while those on the legacy fuboTV Starter Plan have 250 Hours of DVR storage. How do I pause, rewind, ff using cloud dvr in Spectrum app on brand new Samsung Smart TV? Spectrum TV App Supported Devices DVR recording in the cloud JB72 Posts: 7 Participant edited August 2022 Jun 04, 2020 I have moved on from a DVR (machine) to recording into the cloud. Hello and welcome @Dchappy! I apologize, the option to pause and rewind live TV is not available within the Spectrum TV app. In order to pause live TV, there needs to be a recording function in place like the one you find in a DVR or traditional set top box. if you click on that you should get a number of ways you can alter the settings. To do so would require a separate dedicatesd feed for every cable customer. Just try telling ESPN and the NFL or NBA that you want to halt a game in progress! A forum for the discussion of Charter's Spectrum service. Follow the on-screen instructions to complete . To view Spectrum.net, please use another supported browser. signed up for cloud dvr. Spectrum has a legacy TV business to uphold, though, which might explain the hush-hush approach to its streaming options. Why are some scheduled shows not recording? I've also included a couple links for reference as well: How to Record and View Programs on Cloud DVR Cloud DVR (cDVR) and Cloud DVR Plus FAQs Customers without Spectrum Receivers can still use the Cloud DVR (cDVR) and Cloud DVR Plus (cDVR Plus) services offered by Spectrum. I've also included a couple links for reference as well: are there any smart TV that support this? It used to not show previews at all, but I just checked and it does, and it did the preview type thing for the first 60 seconds or so while forwarding, then stopped, but kept forwarding. [ Further reading: The best streaming TV services ]. These are the requirements for using the cDVR service: Additionally, you will require a supported browser with the most recent version, such as. Compared to the excellent Amazon Fire TV Recast however, the $99 AirTV 2 is not (yet) a slick,. Does the feature even exist, or am I not doing something correctly? Sign in or register to get started. And recording using the cloud DVR is unrelated to either devices or streams - a single user can have effectively unlimited recordings at the same time, since they happen back in DirecTV's servers - not on a user device. Pausing while using Spectrum Unfortunately, we have discovered that we cannot pause live tv programs being viewed on Spectrum's application. Google Chromecast first generation or higher. https://www.spectrum.net/support/tv/cdvr-faq, Cloud DVR Recordings stop and revert back to Recordings Menu, California Consumer Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, California Consumer Limit the Use of My Sensitive Personal Information. When you purchase through links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. According to our sources, Spectrum will launch a cloud DVR on April 23, 2019. A forum for the discussion of Charter's Spectrum service. It looks like you're new here. I click on it to the information page where I find the record button. If you're a Spectrum customer and want to know how to stream live TV on your computer, it's simple. I set up recordings for the entire we, I have several series with dozens of episodes recorded. On cloud DVR, you can schedule recordings thus: You can access recorded programs on your device based on their specific program library. To access the information page, choose the program. Goes for a bit with preview then stops the preview but keeps forwarding. It also adds an. DVR Related Recordings. I am getting different answers from calling Spectrum and the technicians. We cannot pause Spectrum Live TV with the Roku. Get Google Chrome Get Apple Safari Get Mozilla Firefox Does cloud dvr let me rewind shows like a set top box? Choose Record. I click on it and am told I can record a series ( either "all" or "new"). And instead of promoting the same bloated cable bundles, Spectrum is offering cheaper, more flexible options. On the following platforms, you can use the Spectrum TV app to access Cloud DVR: The Cloud DVR and Cloud DVR Plus have some differences. You can also use the Live Guide to set up a recording while you browse through the channels just select the title in the Live Guide grid for recording options. Hulu + Live TV includes 50 hours of cloud DVR storage, plus the option to upgrade . Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Compared to most live TV streaming services, Spectrum's. Ad-skipping: No limits on fast forwarding through commercials, and no restrictions on which channels you can record. The current version system software is tvOS 14.7. That is not true Karl. It is a great feature if you travel or are away from home frequently. It shows too! How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? Sorry for any confusion. Enjoy thousands of On Demand shows and movies. We steer you to products you'll love and show you how to get the most out of them. It's good to know once and for all. I went to best buy and the salesperson there said "oh if you have spectrum, you want a samsung" sounds like that may have been bad advice. . Tuners: 16 View DISH plans Jump to review Best third-party DVR TiVo EDGE for Cable Price: $289.99 Resolution: Up to 4K UHD Storage: 300 hrs. In the link that I provided above it shows that cloud DVR is for Internet streaming only and has some limitations. Most units hold around 40 hours of programming; if you want more storage, the price will go up. One of the most significant advantages of the Spectrum cloud DVR is recording videos to watch later. An icon with a red circle and a confirmation message will appear for successfully set recordings. Additionally, you are permitted to watch an unlimited number of streams at home and a maximum of three streams outside the house at once. Every time I press record, the only option is to record "all" or "new" of the series. Charter Communications, which runs Spectrum, lost 145,000 pay TV subscribers last quartercompared to 112,000 lost subscribers the year priorand it shed 287,000 TV subscribers in all of 2018. Xfinity's cable box system works differently than Soectrums. How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? It looks like you're new here. Download the Spectrum TV App and get the most out of your Spectrum TV experience. Also, save until space is needed, or for ninety (90) days (cDVR) or one (1) year (cDVR Plus). What is required for using cDVR? Step 2. A stand-alone set-top DVR unit can cost anywhere from $100 to $1,000, with subscriptions averaging about $13 a month. Just started with Spectrum because chat agent said I could pause live tv. Where can I find things like And when you want to save your favorite games and memorable plays, their cloud DVR has you covered! Find the series you want to record in order to start recording it. CloudDVR only plays recorded content, it does not support recordings that are in progress. Thank you for the info I will check it out. Download the Spectrum TV App on Your Connected Devices Every screen is a TV screen with Spectrum. Pausing and rewinding is supported on CloudDVR recordings. 8.4. Failed to tell me I would not be able to pause live tv even though told him it was a must. new samsung smart tv. This video streaming service also has a $20 monthly add-on which, while it doesn't add any channels, lets you watch 4K livestreams and a limited amount of on-demand content. Sign in or register to get started. Press J to jump to the feed. Spectrums cloud DVR may be stingy, but at least it acts more like a real DVR. You need to have the spectrum Cloud DVR package I believe. Decide to delete the recording. By comparison, the cheapest live TV streaming service that includes local channels is Hulu with Live TV at $45 per month, and most others start at $50 per month. I figured it was a better option, le, I found a thread in Reddit that was older and had no solution. As those losses accelerate, Spectrums streaming TV packages will look less like a last-ditch attempt to prevent cord-cutting, and more like a standard part of its service offerings. Lets start by defining Cloud DVR. Are you trying to record standard Spectrum cable network programming, on-demand channels, or 3rd party streaming using an app on your Apple TV or phone? The feature allows you to rewind and fast-forward live TV, pause a television show, delete and manage recordings, and create instant replays. The Spectrum TV App is supported, but to manage and view Cloud DVR programming you would need a supported device, including Apple & Android smartphones and tablets, Apple TV or ROKU. Just try telling ESPN and the NFL or NBA that you want to halt a game in progress! with cloud dvr and cloud dvr plus you can hit record on a show you are watching and then you are able to pause it. Both packages offer only a subset of the channels that are on cable, and neither include regional sports networks. Before posting a new question, please check out our, You are currently viewing the Spectrum Community Archives. Announcement Closed 1.5K views 0 comments Started By James_M Latest Comment: 12-03-20 by James_M in Cloud DVR Cloud DVR Recordings stop and revert back to Recordings Menu, California Consumer Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, California Consumer Limit the Use of My Sensitive Personal Information. (Spectrum Select would be minimum starting point) and would need a DVR box if you wanted DVR service. Still, cloud DVR is a big step forward for Spectrum, and it demonstrates how cable companies might try to fend off cord-cutting as they continue to bleed traditional TV subscribers. And this is while you are outside your home. This doesn't affect our editorial independence. You cannot share these recordings between Cloud DVR and traditional DVRs. On m, On multiple devices (desktop, iPad, iPhone) playbacks regularly stop playing. CloudDVR only plays recorded content, it does not support recordings that are in progress. 1000 hours Cloud DVR fuboTV includes a cloud DVR with 1000 hours (no expiration). Depending on your recording, select the method. This feature should be able to be added to this service for the price we have to pay. The company only mentions TV Choice to new subscribers who select internet-only plansit still gives top billing to traditional Triple Play packagesand the only way I found about cloud DVR was from an April 22 story on Cord Cutters News, whose anonymous sources said the service would launch the next day. March 2021. Considering going back to YouTube TV if this feature is not added soon. Scheduled Cloud DVR recordings not showing. It looks like you're new here. This question was also asked here: How to pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? It looks like you're new here. Like perhaps a sporting event or the news or something like that. Spectrum never made an official announcement, but instead started quietly offering DVR service to customers who inquired. Sign in or register to get started. I don't want to get rid of the DVR box and plan to use the app, DVR cloud, and Roku if I can no longer pause regular live TV. While the upfront cost of a stand-alone DVR is higher than a leased unit from a TV provider, the investment may pay off over time. LR Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. I see other comments about this and would like to know if this is going to be added any time soon. Catch Up Watch any program that's aired in the last 72 hours (availability varies by network). MLB extra Innings price for 2023. . Currently, this feature is not supported on the Spectrum TV App, however you can add CloudDVR, record programming and watch it at a later time. While I still have some qualms with Spectrums approachmost notably, the inconvenient cancellation process, the sneaky broadcast TV fee, and the way Spectrums apps sometimes list content that requires a pricier packageat least DVR isnt a missing piece anymore. It seems that for full DVR box functionality, you will need Spectrum Traditional TV service. The distinctions are listed in the following features. The data that I can find is Cloud DVR is $10 a month and it allows the recording of 50 hours of shows. DVR can't pause live local TV. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. We currently have been streaming via the the Spectrum app with a Roku on a non-smart TV. I concur! Would you like to learn how to use the Spectrum TV apps cloud DVR? Required Browser Upgrade We're sorry, this browser is no longer supported. In addition to Cloud DVR, you may also want to check out the similar features below. How can I pause and rewind live TV using the Spectrum TV app? I do see that it gives the option to record series. Learn more. Both Spectrum TV Choice and Spectrum TV Stream cost $25 per month plus a broadcast TV fee (which varies, but is $5 per month in the Cincinnati area), so adding DVR would bring the total to $35 per month plus tax. Still, I suspect that Spectrums streaming options will become more prominent over time. Cloud DVR Recordings stop and revert back to Recordings Menu, California Consumer Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, California Consumer Limit the Use of My Sensitive Personal Information. Copyright 2023 IDG Communications, Inc. Price: $5 per month, with one charge covering all devices. I was wondering if you would be able to pause and rewind live TV if you are not recording the program. An unadvertised DVR option makes Spectrum's streaming TV services whole. With Spectrum DVR Service, whenever you watch Live TV the current channel is automatically recorded in the Time Shift Buffer. Learn more about recording live TV on Hulu and get step-by-step instructions here . The Roku Voice Remote Pro, Enhanced Voice Remote, and Gaming Remote include built-in headphone jacks; just plug in and keep watching. Some observers have argued that they merely need to improve their own set-top boxes, as Comcast has done, to more closely resemble the experience of streaming devices, with slicker interfaces, better search, and online video apps built in. I've been on the phone with them for over 2 hours. Before posting a new question, please check out our. For access to the Spectrum TV app, we partner with Samsung. Probably just gonna stay with YTTV lol. Checking your series priority settings will be the right choice. DVR freezing/skipping on recorded shows and paused live tv. The key unique feature about CloudDVR is that you can watch recordings from any device that supports the Spectrum TV app at any location (using wifi or internet data). On cloud DVR, how to delete multiple recordings at once? IE replaying a cool sports plays or something. You can post for technical support, advice, or just to vent. If the Live TV input is already setup, press Home on your Roku TV remote and then perform a or b: Highlight the Live TV input, press Star to bring up the Options menu and select Set up Live TV Pause. When watching live TV shows on Spectrum, you can record them by using the DVR settings. the faq site states that you can access cloud dvr on the Spectrum App, on Roku. Will this issue be soon resolved? This means that you can pause the program and resume where you left off up . Resolution: Up to 4K UHD Storage: 500 hrs. Cloud DVR is available through Spectrum's streaming apps on Apple TV, Roku, Xbox One, Samsung TVs, iOS, Android, and the web. You can record TV shows with Spectrum Cloud DVR and Cloud DVR Plus bundles. The entire service is only $20 a month, and the streaming cloud DVR is included in that price. Verify the selection on the following screen. Something Ive been thinking a lot about lately is what it would take to declare that cable companies have adequately responded to cord-cutting. Start Over Never miss a moment by returning to the beginning of any live program (availability varies by network). Another feature the other services have that Spectrum lacks is PIP. This is very displeasing as the ONLY reason we invested in the new Apple TV was to use Spectrum's because it is the service we require to watch a local sports channel. Now I've opened all the Apple Tvs and if I leave they are . One rep told me Essentials wasnt available yet, while the other said I could only add it without DVR.). You are to select the program youd like to watch for details. Then, click "Watch Live" to start . 1 LiveToSee22 1 yr. ago Oh interesting. Interestingly; they are still independent products and are stored content separately. But one question comes up is it possible to record just one show? Probably record all episodes or new ones. Sign in or register to get started. Hulu with Live TV charges $15-per-month extra for ad-skipping, and YouTube TV requires you to watch ads on CBS channels if an on-demand version of the program is available. Tuners: 6 In order to watch recorded shows and programs, just press the 'My DVR' or 'DVR' button on your Spectrum remote. The Spectrum TV App is supported, but to manage and view Cloud DVR programming you would need a supported device, including Apple & Android smartphones and tablets, Apple TV or ROKU. First, visit watch.spectrum.net and sign in with your login credentials to start watching instantly. Can the Cloud DVR be updated to only keep one show instead of 365 days or out of space? With Spectrums TV Choice and TV Stream plans, which are available if you have internet service through the cable company, you can now add cloud DVR service for $5 per month. Spectrum is inching ever closer to competing in earnest with cord-cutting, although the company doesnt seem eager to let people know about it. It used to not show previews at all, but I just checked and it does, and it did the preview type thing for the first 60 seconds or so while forwarding, then stopped, but kept forwarding . Verify the selection on the following screen. It seems that for full DVR box functionality, you will need Spectrum Traditional TV service. I found a page that answers some of your questions here: Ok. Also, after choosing, select confirm or record. Stream live TV anywhere you have a connection. We can't test this out first, as we were told we can't have both the cloud and the box. ANNKE 8 Channel 5MP Lite Security DVR Recorder with 1TB Hard Drive, H.265+ Hybrid 5-in-1 Surveillance DVR, Human & Vehicle Detection, Supports 8CH Analog and 2 IP Cameras for 24/7 Home CCTV. Cloud DVR plus allows for the recording of 100 hours of shows, but I can't find a price for that plan. Yes, an internet connection is required to play recordings. I find a show I want to record. Your cDVR and cDVR Plus recordings are accessible from a variety of platforms. Learn more. At this time, Live TV cannot be paused using the Spectrum TV App on any device, including Roku. Please confirm that we can indeed pause live TV when streaming with the Roku if we get rid of the box and use the spectrum app and cloud. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Or series that you might have record in the . New to Spectrum and I am having the same reoccurring problem. Cloud DVR Recordings stop and revert back to Recordings Menu, California Consumer Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, California Consumer Limit the Use of My Sensitive Personal Information. you can only pause a show you are currently recording or have already recorded. Pausing a live broacast in progress is not like stopping a DVR and resuming. Sign in or register to get started. Apple TV 4K, tvOS 14. On this screen, tap on the 'Recordings' tab from the left sidebar and you will be able to see a list of all the programs. Storage: Save up to 50 programs, regardless of length, for up to 90 days. I want to be able to pause live tv as well All of the other live streaming providers have the ability to pause live tv.. the lack of this feature was the main reason i canceled my Spectrum Tv service(i went with the Apple TV only plan), the other was the $17 charge for locals(ugh).. anyway, please add the ability to pause live tv!!!!! Or do a season pass? Based on this post, it sounds like that is not possible?